| Category |
Text Publication |
| Reference Category |
Journals |
| DOI |
10.1111/1365-2664.70565
|
Licence  |
|
| Title (Primary) |
Factors influencing the use of scientific evidence in conservation practice and policy: Insights from a systematic map |
| Author |
Martin, P.A.; Amirmohammedi, F.; Barreto, C.; Berger, I.; Bissessur, P.; Christie, A.P.; Donoso, I.; Furlan, V.; Grainger, M.J.; Hartup, J.; Keith, A.M.; Ki, T. L.T.; Littlewood, N.A.; Luke, S.H.; Matos, C.; Moser, V.; Mukherjee, N.; Martínez de Birgara, E.; Moreno Martínez, Á.; Ollard, I.; Oswald, A.M.; Perea, S.; Taberer, T.R.; Takola, E.
; Thornhill, I.; Zafra-Calvo, N.; Walsh, J.C.; Oliver, K. |
| Source Titel |
Journal of Applied Ecology |
| Year |
2026 |
| Department |
CLE |
| Volume |
63 |
| Issue |
9 |
| Page From |
e70565 |
| Language |
englisch |
| Topic |
T5 Future Landscapes |
| Data and Software links |
https://doi.org/10.5281/ZENODO.22032391 |
| Supplements |
Supplement 1 |
| Keywords |
barriers; evidence use; evidence-based conservation; evidence-informed conservation; facilitators; knowledge co-production; knowledge exchange; science–practice gap |
| Abstract |
Evidence-based conservation has the potential to improve
biodiversity outcomes. Yet many conservation decisions do not explicitly
incorporate scientific evidence, despite efforts to promote its use. To
strengthen the role of scientific evidence in informing conservation
decisions, it is vital to understand which factors influence its use by
decision makers. However, to date, there has been no comprehensive
attempt to characterise the scientific literature on this topic.
To fill this knowledge gap, we conducted a systematic
map to synthesise the literature on factors that impact evidence use in
conservation decision-making, including identifying where research has
been conducted and which actors have been studied. Our searches and
screening identified 169 relevant primary studies.
We identified an apparent bias in the evidence use
literature towards English-speaking countries in the Global North. Few
studies reported focal ecosystems, or threats, but those that did often
focused on marine, forest or freshwater systems. The majority of studies
investigated practitioners and researchers as actors, with relatively
few studies focused on policymakers or other actors.
The most commonly reported factors influencing
evidence use were relationships between scientists and decision makers,
the relevance of evidence and the capacity and resources of conservation
organisations. Factors relating to the characteristics of evidence and
practitioners/policymakers, including their organisations and decision
contexts, were frequently referenced. However, few studies identified
factors relating to researchers and research organisations.
Synthesis and applications. Researchers should
move from characterising factors impacting scientific evidence use to
identifying and testing interventions to facilitate its use by
conservation decision makers. Since these factors are interlinked,
implementation and testing of actions that tackle multiple barriers
should be prioritised. Decision makers and researchers should engage
with each other early on when defining management, policy and research
synthesis questions, define knowledge needs clearly and, where possible,
invest in mechanisms to facilitate dialogue and interpretation of
evidence. Together, these approaches offer the potential to promote
evidence-based conservation practice and policy, resulting in improved
biodiversity outcomes. |
Martin, P.A., Amirmohammedi, F., Barreto, C., Berger, I., Bissessur, P., Christie, A.P., Donoso, I., Furlan, V., Grainger, M.J., Hartup, J., Keith, A.M., Ki, T. L.T., Littlewood, N.A., Luke, S.H., Matos, C., Moser, V., Mukherjee, N., Martínez de Birgara, E., Moreno Martínez, Á., Ollard, I., Oswald, A.M., Perea, S., Taberer, T.R., Takola, E., Thornhill, I., Zafra-Calvo, N., Walsh, J.C., Oliver, K. (2026):
Factors influencing the use of scientific evidence in conservation practice and policy: Insights from a systematic map
J. Appl. Ecol. 63 (9), e70565
10.1111/1365-2664.70565 |