Publication Details

Category Text Publication
Reference Category Journals
DOI 10.1016/j.ecolecon.2016.01.006
Title (Primary) Exploring group dynamics in deliberative choice experiments
Author Völker, M.; Lienhoop, N.
Source Titel Ecological Economics
Year 2016
Department OEKON
Volume 123
Page From 57
Page To 67
Language englisch
Keywords Choice certainty; Choice modeling; Deliberative monetary valuation; Group dynamics; Initial preference distribution; Preference adjustment
UFZ wide themes RU6;
Abstract Deliberative monetary valuation has emerged as a promising alternative to conventional stated preference studies of ecosystem services. It promises to give respondents a better basis for decision-making by exposing them to a more diverse set of knowledge, arguments and opinions through group discussion. However, under certain conditions, small groups may fail to effectively pool the individual knowledge of their members. This paper examines the impact of the initial distribution of individual preferences in discussion groups on the outcome of deliberative choice experiments. Drawing on a deliberative monetary valuation study of forest ecosystem services in West Saxony, Germany, it is shown that the initial preference distribution in groups influences both the diversity of arguments exchanged during group discussions and respondents' consideration of the costs of environmental policies. Furthermore, results indicate that respondents' post-discussion willingness-to-pay is affected by the initial preference distribution in groups, though these changes were not statistically significant. The choice certainty of respondents was found to remain largely unaffected. Overall, the empirical findings of this study provide preliminary evidence about the need to conduct future deliberative monetary valuation studies with groups with heterogeneous initial preferences as this may provide respondents with a more complete set of decision-relevant information.
Persistent UFZ Identifier
Völker, M., Lienhoop, N. (2016):
Exploring group dynamics in deliberative choice experiments
Ecol. Econ. 123 , 57 - 67 10.1016/j.ecolecon.2016.01.006