Although natural toxins, such as mycotoxins or phytoestrogens are widely studied and were recently identified as micropollutants in the environment, many of their environmentally relevant physicochemical properties have not yet been determined. Here, the sorption affinity to Pahokee peat, a model sorbent for soil organic matter, was investigated for 29 mycotoxins and two phytoestrogens. Sorption coefficients (K_oc) were determined with a dynamic HPLC-based column method using a fully aqueous mobile phase with 5 mM CaCl₂ at pH 4.5. Sorption coefficients varied from less than 10^0.7 L/kg_oc (e.g., all type B trichothecenes) to 10^4.0 L/kg_oc (positively charged ergot alkaloids). For the neutral compounds the experimental sorption data set was compared with predicted sorption coefficients using various models, based on molecular fragment approaches (EPISuite’s KOCWIN or SPARC), poly parameter linear free energy relationship (pp-LFER) in combination with predicted descriptors, and quantum-chemical based software (COSMOtherm)). None of the available models was able to adequately predict absolute K_oc numbers and relative differences in sorption affinity for the whole set of neutral toxins, largely because mycotoxins exhibit highly complex structures. Hence, at present, for such compounds fast and consistent experimental techniques for determining sorption coefficients, as the one used in this study, are required.